The Deliverance vs. Demon House: 4 Ways They Differ

“The Deliverance may become one of the best horror movies on Netflix in 2024,” Screen Rant proclaimed. Why? One very specific reason: “due to its terrifying use of demonic possession.” Well, that and the fact a true story inspired it, “making it scarier and more unnerving for audiences.”

I think Screen Rant is on to something. The Deliverance very well could follow in the footsteps of other acclaimed horror movies inspired by alleged real-life possessions, like The Exorcist, The Amityville Horror, and The Conjuring. Especially since, also like those films, The Deliverance boasts a star-studded cast. So, yeah. The ingredients exist for a terrifying treat.

But it was the “inspired by true events” part that intrigued me. What case was it? One I was familiar with or something new?

A Variety list of the 22 best movies streaming in August provided the answer:

“Lee Daniels is back in the director’s chair for Netflix’s ‘The Deliverance,’ a new horror-thriller that follows a family living in Indiana who are plagued by supernatural and demonic occurrences that lead them and their community to believe their house is a portal to hell.”

Specifically, it was the “Indiana” and “portal to hell” details that cinched it.

The Demon House Documentary

Latoya Ammons, her three children, and her mother allegedly endured demonic possession in the house that once stood at 3860 Carolina Street in Gary, Indiana, where they lived from 2011-2012.

In 2014, Zak Bagans purchased the house “sight unseen” after the Ghost Adventures star learned of Ammons’ haunted house story. Then he took his crew there and conducted a paranormal investigation. In 2016, he tore down the house. In 2018, he released the Demon House documentary.

Bagans billed it as “the most documented case of demonic possession in US history” for good reason. Ammons and her family weren’t the only witnesses to the paranormal activity plaguing them. In Demon House, Bagans interviewed staff from the Gary Police Department, the Department of Child Services, and a hospital who also saw it. But, curiously, not Ammons because she’d already struck a deal with another production company. (Which ended up going belly up, but another one came along and ended up making The Deliverance.)

A “view at your own risk” warning accompanied the Demon House trailer because Bagans believed the house was cursed. Except, he didn’t think you even necessarily needed to step foot in it for the demons to curse you. The documentary itself carried a similar “viewer beware” warning, which stated:

The following documentary may not be suitable for all audiences. This film shows real people, places and events involving alleged demonic possession. Demonologists believe that demons can attach themselves to you through other people, objects, and electronic devices.

Was it as haunted and cursed as Bagans made it out to be? We’ll never know. (I saw the documentary and was fine, just like everyone else who saw it was.) But the bummer is that no one else will ever get the chance to verify or debunk his claims since the house is gone. However, he did save the stairs, which he displays in his museum.

The Deliverance vs. Demon House: Differences

1. Format

While the same story inspired both, and both are feature-length films, the most obvious difference is the format. Demon House was a documentary about a paranormal investigation after the fact. The Deliverance is a supernatural horror movie about the paranormal events as they unfold.

2. The House

Since the original house was torn down, it obviously wasn’t available to film in. (Would they have, though, even if they could? Or would that have been too creepy?)

But the original was a single-story wooden house. The house in The Deliverance is a two-story brick.

3. Names

Similar to what Netflix did with The Watcher, The Deliverance keeps many of the details from the real-life story but changes certain things, like the names of those involved. For instance, Andra Day’s “Ebony” portrays Latoya Ammons, and Glen Close’s “Alberta” portrays Ammons’ mom, Rosa Campbell.

4. The Grandma

Speaking of the grandma, in a curious casting choice that I’d love to ask Lee Daniels about, he picked Glenn Close. So many of the comments on the trailer expressed excitement to see the talented, Oscar-nominated actor in the film. (Myself included. I mean, come on. “It’s Glenn f–king Close!” to borrow one person’s comment.)

However, how come no one questioned the obvious? Close’s skin color doesn’t match that of the woman her character is based on. Maybe they’re not familiar with the real story? Because for those who are, I imagine this is a question that might come up. (Well, I guess I’m proof of that, aren’t I?)

Not that it should matter. People reported that Day had nothing except praise for the “absolute veteran.” And Close felt the same, saying being part of the movie was “one of the best, most joyous, challenging and humbling experiences of my career.”

Still, I couldn’t help but wonder if phenoms like Pam Grier (who rocked the grandma role in THEM: The Scare), Alfre Woodard, Phylicia Rashad (maybe she had a Gilded Age conflict?), Loretta Devine, or Angela Bassett were offered the part.

I’m sure Lee had his reasons. It’s not like the Oscar winner doesn’t know what he’s doing, after all. Judging from the trailer, Close does what she does best: owns her role. I’m just doing what I do best: being nosy.

I will say it makes me even more curious to see The Deliverance, which opens in theaters on August 16 and starts streaming on Netflix on August 30. What about you?

Check-In

Does the fact The Deliverance is based on a true story up the scare factor for you?